The Dream Of America
Indiana, my home state, has a new license plate. Along
with the usual expiration dates, the individual
license number, and the state name, it now also bears
a motto that gives this blogger pause, to say the
least. Before I tell you what it says, and why I take
issue with it, I am going to give you a bit of my own
history, or of the history that, as a child, I
bought--hook, line, and sinker.
American children are taught (at least they were back
when I was in grammar school) that The U.S. is the
great "Melting Pot", that America is uniquely
wonderful not only due to a relatively new and
experimental undertaking called Democracy, but due to
the rich, intricately woven culture that was born from
our multicultural stone-soupness. One can achieve
ANYTHING, be ANYTHING, spend every Wednesday night
howling at the moon in one's front yard, and, with the
Constitutionally mandated Separation of Church and
State, worship any way one chooses--not how any King
or President would deem appropriate. My
textbooks stated that in becoming Americans, even the
poorest of the poor, the meekest of the meek, could
absolutely reverse their fortunes--from oppressed to
free, from exiled to welcomed, just by showing up.
Many did just that. My own ancestors arrived here
around the end of the Civil War (late 18th
Century)from Ireland, Germany and Denmark.
This idealized version of America fascinated my little kid mind. I
loved it! I adored my country. I envisioned my people
crossing the Atlantic to what must have truly felt
like a new world. I was proud of them. I was proud
that we, as Americans honored our cultural
tributaries, honored all the myriad strains of
humanity that became the whole, honored the meek who
came with nothing and built new lives as well as built
a new nation for themselves (and for us). E Pluribus
Unum--"Out of Many, One" This was "America". This same
motto used to grace all American currency, and it was
PERFECT--a fantastic and, most importantly, INCLUSIVE
metaphor for America. This, by the way, is what
should be on my license plate--and what WOULD be if my
childhood Social-Studies vision of The U.S. was even
half true.
The new Indiana license plate reads: "In God We
Trust".
And now, the obligatory defense: my personal
relationship with, feelings about, sense of, habits
relating to, like, dislike, awe of, love or disdain
for religion are beside the point. State money
should not be utilized to fund this message. Period. There is no
historical tradition or precedent in license plating
to support it being Constitutionally OK. That aside,
the greater issue is the exclusiveness of it. You can
bet that there will never be a state funded plate that reads,
"Allah Blesses You", or "May The Blessings Of Kali Be
Yours". In Judaism, the word for God is neither spoken
or written, so it can't be said that this state-funded
plate--in a nation that purports to upholds the
Separation of Church and State--is deity inclusive. It
isn't. It matters not at all if the majority of
Americans are Christians, people are free to blanket
their vehicles with "In God We Trust" stickers, if
they so choose. Just not with stickers paid for with
tax dollars.
It is often said that this country was/is based on Judeo
-Christian values--that that is what justifies such
things as representations of God on our license
plates, in our courthouses, etc. But I really don't know
how this one slipped by. People seem, rather
conveniently, to forget that The U.S. Government has
been SECULAR from day one. There are VERY good reasons for this vital mandate. The U.S. is not a Theocracy--and thank God, I say.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Never miss an email again!
Yahoo! Toolbar alerts you the instant new Mail arrives.
http://tools.search.yahoo.com/toolbar/features/mail/







